Top 6 Things to Do in New York's Coney Island in Winter

Wander Brooklyn's Atlantic Ocean Boardwalk, Eat Famous Coney Island Pizza

Coney island winter
••• aluxum / Getty Images

A visit to Brooklyn's Coney Island off-season —especially in winter — makes for a bracing experience. It's eerie and dramatic: the open sky, the ocean, and the skeleton of Coney Island's famous Cyclones rollercoaster and Parachute Jump.

Coney Island in the wintertime is beautiful in an isolated, industrial-urban-landscape kind of way. It's the perfect pensive escape from the urban hustle and bustle.

Coney Island's amusement park and beach are closed September through May. But there's plenty to do, and eat, and dream about as you wander the area off-season. Come prepared for brisk ocean breezes.

Edited by Alison Lowenstein

  • 01 of 06

    Zen Out at the New York Aquarium

    Penguin Swimming On Water Surface
    ••• Pablo López Learte / EyeEm / Getty Images

    New York City's world-class aquarium has wonderful exhibits and scheduled fish-feeding shows. Open year-round, with both indoor and outdoor exhibits, the Aquarium makes for a nice date and good family fun. And, for those so inclined, it's nothing less than mesmerizing to watch the fish go about their daily rounds...and rounds...and rounds.

  • 02 of 06
    Coney Island Wonder Wheel snow
    ••• aluxum / Getty Images

    New York’s most famous boardwalk offers views of the rolling Atlantic Ocean on one side, Coney Island’s rides and amusement park on the other — and great people-watching in-between.

    Here's a suggested itinerary for tourists and first-time visitors. Start at Coney Island, and walk all the way to Brighton Beach. There you can find a good, hot bowl of authentic Russian borscht. Then, head back home on the subway. You'll feel like you've been away for a month.

    Or, if you happen to like running, or walking in charity races, check out the Thanksgiving Turkey Trot in Coney Island

  • 03 of 06

    Eat a Nathan's Hot Dog at the Original Hot Dog Stand

    Nathan's hot dogs Coney Island
    ••• aluxum / Getty Images

    Nathan's is hardly a mom-and-pop anymore. With about eight thousand Nathan’s Famous hot dog stands in the world, it's a global franchise. But this one in Coney Island was the original. Some people swear the dogs here taste better. (And yes, it's an indoor hot dog stand.)

  • 04 of 06

    Feast on Classic Brooklyn Pizza at Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano

    Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitano
    ••• Joe Hall / Flickr / CC BY 2.0

    It's hard to beat a Totonno's pizza, even in as serious a pizza-eating place as Brooklyn. It stands out head and shoulders among the hundreds of local pizzerias you'll find dotting every neighborhood in the borough. Why? The thin crust and fresh sauce, and everything else you're wolfing down with pleasure, are all made on the premises. The pizza is baked in a brick oven. And, it tastes great just because Totonno's is a Coney Island institution.

    Thankfully, Totonno's hasn't let all the Zagat raves and attention go to their heads. They know what they're doing is just ... making pizza.

    As for decor, it's as minimal as the pizza crust is thin.

    Continue to 5 of 6 below.
  • 05 of 06
    ••• Great Coney Island Spectacularium" installation by J.Ebenstein and A.Beebe.Photo by Brad Paris. Great Coney Island Spectacularium" installation by J.Ebenstein and A.Beebe.Photo by Brad Paris

    This idiosyncratic little museum is dedicated to preserving Coney Island’s unique history. Entrance costs a whopping ninety-nine cents. This is not a case where you get what you paid for, however. What you'll get is a whiff of the unsanitized, zany, freak show side of Coney Island of yesteryear.

    The museum has old photos, antiques, memorabilia, and relics of Coney's past. In addition, you might catch a special exhibit, lectures and performances, and internship programs. Note: Currently closed for repairs due to damage incurred during Hurricane Sandy in 2012.

  • 06 of 06

    Watch (or Join) the Coney Island Polar Bears New Year's Day Ocean Dip

    Coney Island Polar Bear Plunge
    ••• Stephanie Keith / Stringer / Getty Images


    Starting a new year with an icy dip is a great Brooklyn tradition. The Coney Island Polar Bear Club claims to be the nation’s  oldest winter bathing organization. Hundreds of New York Polar Bears gather in Coney Island every New Year's Day for a dip in the Atlantic Ocean, whatever the weather. It may be lunatic, but it's a party. And, its free. There’s no fee for swimmers or observers. 

    Go ahead and join in the freezing fun! It's a brag that will last a lifetime.

    Alternatively, you can just say you did it. And to convince the folks back home, here's where you can buy a Coney Island Polar Bear t-shirt.

    In a Brooklyn nutshell: Coney Island is a place for all seasons.