Indianapolis Consignment Shops

Dress in style for less!

There's a lot of great shopping in the city of Indianapolis, but if you want to get new fashions at great prices, local consignment stores are the way to go. Not only can you get extra cash for your gently used items, but you can also walk away with a bag full of items for way less than retail. If you enjoy wearing designer labels for a fraction of the price, consignment shopping is something to consider. Buying at these shops is sure to save you money!

  • 01 of 06
    Consignment
    ••• Credit: Susanne Friedrich/E+/Getty Images

    The Toggery has been in business for over 29 years. Located in Broad Ripple, it is one of the premier consignment stores in Indiana and the Midwest. The Toggery specializes in women's designer clothing and accessories and regularly feature fashion designers such as Steve McQueen, Marc Jacobs, Louis Vuitton, Prada, Chanel and Dior.

    The Toggery Resale Boutique
    1810 Broadripple Avenue
    Indianapolis, IN 46220
    317-257-5661

  • 02 of 06
    Dress Shopping
    ••• Credit: Paper Boat Creative/Getty Images

    Butterfly Consignment offers high quality and designer apparel, handbags, shoes, jewelry, perfume, and accessories. The store features a variety of styles - casual to formal and sizes (juniors, misses, and plus). The store retails gently used clothing, unsold new inventory from local boutiques and handmade jewelry, handbags, headbands, soap, body butter, knit creations, greeting cards.

    Butterfly Consignment
    6697 East 82nd Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46250
    317-594-0000

  • 03 of 06
    Sales Rack
    ••• Credit: PeopleImages/Getty Images

    Simply Chic focuses on style and fashion at great prices. The store buys and sells gently used clothing and accessories. Specializing in career clothing, Simply Chic has something perfect for the modern woman.

    Simply Chic - Fishers
    7822 East 96th Street
    Fishers, IN 46038
    317-576-1300

    Simply Chic - Indianapolis
    1204 West 86th Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46260
    317-574-1200

  • 04 of 06
    Shopping
    ••• Credit: Dan Dalton/Caiamages/Getty Images

    Plato's Closet is a nation-wide consignment store that buys and sells the latest looks in brand name gently used clothing and accessories for teen and twenty something guys and girls. The chain has four locations in the Indianapolis area.

    Plato's Closet Fishers
    8680 East 96th Street
    Fishers, IN 46038
    317-585-0868

    Plato's Closet Greenwood
    7775 South US 31
    Greenwood, IN 46227
    317-888-9998

    Plato's Closet Indianapolis
    8238 Rockville Road
    Indianapolis, IN 46214
    317-271-1234

    Plato's Closet Indianapolis
    9782 E. US Highway 36
    Avon, IN 46123
    317-271-1234

    Plato's Closet Indianapolis
    9972 East Washington St
    Indianapolis, IN 46229
    317-895-1930

    Continue to 5 of 6 below.
  • 05 of 06
    Clothes racks
    ••• Credit: Dan Dalton/Moments/Getty Images

    Located on the southside of Indianapolis, Selective Seconds has over 5000 square feet of shopping for women's and junior's fashion and accessories. The store is open daily with over 1000 new items arriving each week.

    Selective Seconds Consignment
    1140 North Street Road
    Greenwood, IN 46142
    317-888-2300

  • 06 of 06
    Shopping Girl
    ••• Credit: btrenkel/E+/Getty Images

    Off The Hanger is a consignment store for men, women and juniors clothing and accessories. Off The Hanger is almost 5,000 square feet and has a wide section of items sizes XS – 5X. There’s something for everyone at Off the Hanger.

    Off The Hanger Consignment‎
    8944 Saint Peter Street
    Indianapolis, IN 46227
    317-881-2900