Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products and services; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Sorel Women’s Caribou Boots at Amazon "Features a durable, cozy design."
Best for Extra Warmth: L.L. Bean Shearling-Lined Boot at L.L. Bean "Praised as the brand's most comfortable yet."
Best for Style: Dr. Martens Leonore Sherpa Chelsea Boots at Shopbop"Doesn;t sacrifice warmth with its thick faux-fur-lining."
Best for Durability: Timberland Premium Waterproof Boot at Nordstrom "Constructed out of premium, water-resistant leather."
Best Lightweight: UGG Women's Cecile Winter Boot at Amazon "Both sophisticated and functional."
Best for Comfort: Columbia Women's Heavenly Mid Calf Boot at Amazon "Has a luxurious faux-fur collar and a plush quilted texture."
Best Tall: Sorel Women's Joan Of Arctic Boot at Amazon "Offer excellent weather protection in tall, snowy banks."
Best for Rain: Hunter Women's Snow Boots at Amazon "Flaunts a high gloss finish and a warm polyester lining."
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Sorel Women’s Caribou Boots
Sorel’s iconic Caribou Boots are a top winter shoe pick because of its durable, cozy design. They're great for most winter activities, even those in heavy snow. They’ll keep your feet toasty in subzero temperatures, coming with a recycled felt ThermoPlus lining with a plush sherpa snow cuff for extra style. In fact, they last in temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit. Plus, you won't need to worry about getting them wet because the soft nubuck shoes have been vulcanized to prevent water damage. They also have seam-sealed waterproof rubber shell outsoles to keep water from seeping into them. For comfortable, safe walking, the Caribou Boots feature Sorel’s AeroTract non-loading outsoles, while the pebbled design allows for steady steps in icy, snowy conditions. For colors, you can choose from buff, black/stone, and shale/stone.
In terms of consideration, just be sure to size down, as the boots run about one size larger than expected.
Best for Extra Warmth: L.L. Bean Tumbled-Leather Shearling-Lined Boot
Nothing beats classic outdoor brand L.L. Bean, which has handcrafted boots in Maine since 1912. These duck boots are praised as its most comfortable yet, and with good reason: they’re lined with premium shearling that’s not only soft but also extremely warm. The boots are also constructed out of full-grain leather for a cozy, snug fit, while the water-resistant rubber bottom protects your feet from heavy rainfall. Although they retail for $229, you get long-lasting boots that will stand up against the coldest of winters.
Best for Style: Dr. Martens Leonore Sherpa Chelsea Boots
If you’re not into the look of traditional winter boots, opt for this Chelsea Boot from Dr. Martens. Along with a slim, stylish silhouette, the leather boots don’t sacrifice warmth with its thick faux-fur-lining. These shoes also feature Dr. Martens’ signature grooved edges, visible stitching, and heel-loop. As with all of the brand’s boots, these shoes are comfortable and durable, thanks to the air-cushioned sole. The low-heeled style also makes it the perfect pair with cropped jeans or long skirts.
Best for Durability: Timberland 6-Inch Premium Waterproof Boot
Another great player in the winter boot space, Timberland’s waterproof boots are an iconic, durable pair. It’s constructed out of premium, water-resistant leather to keep you comfortable and dry in any weather condition. Plus, waterproof seam-sealed construction keeps the boots in good shape. Although tough, the boots feature a padded collar around the ankle and an anti-fatigue sole for even more comfort. These rugged, yet stylish boots can also be paired with jeans on an outdoor excursion or with a dress for a night out.
Best Lightweight: UGG Women's Cecile Winter Boot
Most people associate the UGG brand with their comfy, casual classic booties, but these lightweight Cecile boots are both sophisticated and functional. Sporting a duck boot design, the shoes flaunt a sleek, streamlined look with a full-grain waterproof leather shaft that measures seven inches. Colorwise, you can choose between black and chestnut models. Besides their sophisticated look, these shoes are also warm and comfortable to walk in. The outsole consists of clear spider rubber with cork for traction and comfort. On the inside, their UGGpure wool liners aren't plush but still feel cozy. The shoes are also seam-sealed and waterproof, coming with water guard Pedair foam insoles that make them appropriate for wet winter days.
Best for Comfort: Columbia Women's Heavenly Omni-Heat Mid Calf Boot
Columbia's Heavenly line elevates the white boot trend with a luxurious faux-fur collar and a plush quilted texture. The upper part is made of waterproof woven synthetic textile, so it won't get easily discolored or damaged by snow and soil. Other stylish details include the laces, as well as the metal rivets and aglets that align them. Besides white, the shoes also come in green, gray, black, or navy. The Heavenly boots feature Omni-Heat reflective warmth technology that retains body heat. In addition, the shoes use 200g insulation to keep your feet warm and toasty, rated for temperatures down to -25 degrees Fahrenheit. These boots also have non-marking Omni-Grip outsoles that offer superior traction.
Best Tall: Sorel Women's Joan Of Arctic Boot
These tall winter boots, made from waterproof full-grain leather and suede, are designed for heavy snow. Their shaft height measures approximately 12 inches, so the boots offer excellent weather protection in tall, snowy banks. Due to their length, the shoes weigh almost two pounds each, so they're not the best shoes for high levels of activity. They do, however, keep a lot of heat in — the soft faux fur collar, besides adding a stylish flourish, serves to seal out the cold. The boots also have thick, recycled felt inside to provide insulation. For extra protection, each shoe undergoes seam-sealing, and the outsole is delicately handcrafted with waterproof vulcanized rubber that has a herringbone pattern. The heel is approximately one inch, so there’s adequate buffer space between your feet and the ground during very cold seasons. Colorwise, the shoes mostly come in understated black, gray, and brown hues. That being said, you can choose from over 25 different combinations of boot color and laces for the Joan of Arctic model.
Best for Rain: Hunter Women's Original Short Gloss Snow Boots
Not all winter destinations call for snow boots. For rainy weather, the Original Short Gloss Rain Boots from Hunter will keep your feet dry. The brand has been around for over 160 years, and these high-quality shoes live up to its name. The rain boots are fully waterproof, flaunting a high gloss finish and a warm polyester lining. The non-slip rubber outsoles have tread patterns that keep you steady on your feet even when you face stormy weather conditions. Reasonably priced at under $100, the boots are handcrafted from 28 different parts. Additionally, Hunter produces these boots in over 15 different colors including orange, violet, yellow, and pale blue.