Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products and services; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Minus33 Merino Wool Ridge Cuff Beanie at Amazon
"With unmatched softness, comfort, and breathability."
Runner-Up, Best Overall: Mountain Hardwear Perignon Hat at Amazon
"Comfortable and keeps you dry and warm throughout inclement weather."
Best Budget: Carhartt Acrylic Watch Hat at Amazon
"Retails around half the cost of other winter hats in the market."
Best Style: Everlane The ReCashmere Beret at Everlane
"Styled like a traditional beret with a softer construction."
Best for Toddlers: L.L.Bean Hi-Pile Hat at L.L.Bean
"Plush and cozy enough for toddlers to spend the day playing winter activities."
Best with Pom-Pom: Topshop Faux Fur Pom Beanie at Nordstrom
"Its faux-fur pom-pom makes for a great fashion statement."
Best Trapper Hat: J.Crew Trapper Hat with Faux-Fur Trim at J.Crew
"Comes in a festive tartan pattern."
Best Down Hat: Outdoor Research Transcendent Beanie at Amazon
"Uses responsibly sourced 650-fill power goose down."
Best for Running: Under Armour ColdGear Infrared Beanie at Amazon
"Absorbs and retains about 10-percent of body heat to your head."
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Minus33 Merino Wool Ridge Cuff Beanie
The Minus33 Merino Wool Ridge Cuff Beanie is a stylish cap with unmatched softness, comfort, and breathability. Merino wool is incredibly soft, as well as moisture-wicking, odor-resistant, and insulating. Even when you start to sweat while participating in winter sports or a brisk walk, you'll be able to rely on this winter hat to keep you warm, dry, and fresh. In fact, you can wear it while playing in the snow — the wool can absorb up to 30-percent of its weight in moisture. The lightweight material is naturally elastic, and the circumference ranges from 17 to 25 inches, so you won't need to worry about fit. Best of all? You can toss it in your washer and dryer when you want to clean it. The collection has 11 different colors, including all the hues of the rainbow and more.
Runner-Up, Best Overall: Mountain Hardwear Perignon Hat
Whether you're rock climbing or snowboarding, Mountain Hardware's Perignon Hat is a workhorse hat that's comfortable and keeps you dry and warm throughout winter's inclement weather. This winter hat gets the job done — it completely covers your ears and has an inner fleece-lined ear band for extra warmth. The Perignon also reaches the back of your neck, which is also particularly sensitive to the cold. The beanie, made from 100-percent polyester Toasty Tweed Fleece, has Mountain Hardwear's Windbloc technology so it's breathable and resistant against biting winds. It's also stretchy, so it can accommodate different head sizes. The hat does weigh four ounces, so it's a hair heavier than many other options in the market that weigh one to two ounces.
Best Budget: Carhartt Acrylic Watch Hat
This best-selling, cult-favorite beanie has thousands of positive reviews, and with good reason: it's warm, comfortable, and retails around half the cost of other winter hats in the market. It's made of stretchable, acrylic rib-knit fabric for a one-size-fits-all hat, while the classic, simple style goes with any outfit. Carhartt, which has been making these hats in the U.S. since 1987, ensures durability with every construction. The winter hat also comes in a variety of colors, like green, black, orange, red, gold, brown, blue, and more. Although it's labeled for men, this unisex beanie is perfect for women, too.
Best Style: Everlane The ReCashmere Beret
Leave it to ethically-sourced brand Everlane to deliver some of the most stylish, high-quality winter accessories, like the ReCashmere Beret. Styled like a traditional beret with a softer construction, this winter hat is made of 60 percent recycled cashmere and 40 percent wool. And, true to Everlane's sustainable mission, the beret is also crafted with premium Italian yarn that's been recycled for 50 percent less impact — meaning it feels like 100 percent cashmere with half of the carbon footprint. Choose from red, black, and sand.
Best for Toddlers: L.L.Bean Hi-Pile Hat
Keep your little ones toasty with the adorable Hi-Pile hat from L.L. Bean. Constructed of 100 percent polyester fleece, this winter hat is plush and cozy enough for toddlers to spend the day sledding, ice skating, or playing with snow. Plus, the furry bear ears are a cute touch. With sizes including 6-12 months, 12-24 months, and 2T-4T, reviewers praised the comfortable fit of the hat. Colors include navy and white, and the hat can be machine-washed and dried.
Best with Pom-Pom: Topshop Faux Fur Pom Beanie
Pom-poms are a fun way to add flair to the traditional knit beanie, and this Topshop Faux Fur Pom Beanie is no exception. Its acrylic, polyester, and wool blend will keep your head warm and comfortable during snow and wintry days, while the eye-catching, faux-fur pom-pom makes for a great fashion statement. Machine washable, this winter hat is available in four colors, including black, grey, mustard, and lime.
Best Trapper Hat: J.Crew Trapper Hat with Faux-Fur Trim
The trapper hat, which was first worn by Norwegian Arctic explorers and fighter pilots during World War I, gets a refresh with this stylish number from J.Crew. Like traditional trapper hats, this winter hat is made to keep you extremely warm with its ear flaps and faux-fur trim. Even more, the winter hat comes in a festive tartan pattern — perfect for the holiday season. Note that it only comes in one size and is recommended to dry clean.
Best Down Hat: Outdoor Research Transcendent Beanie
Since down jackets exist, why not down hats? Outdoor Research’s Transcendent Beanie, which hails from the same product line as the popular Transcendent jacket, has an ultralight and water-resistant ripstop shell. Inside, it uses responsibly sourced 650-fill power goose down. The beanie helps you retain heat during winter treks, and when the temperature gets warm, all you need to do is stuff it into its hidden pocket or compress it. The winter hat won't be too heavy to carry around as it weighs a mere ounce in total. One thing to keep in mind is that reviewers have mentioned sizing issues. To play it safe, go with a large/x-large size as opposed to a small/medium one.
Best for Running: Under Armour ColdGear Infrared Beanie
If you need something that will fit under your helmet and keep your head warm, look no further than Under Armour's ColdGear Infrared Beanie. The "infrared" part of the name refers to the thermo-conductive inner coating of the beanie which absorbs and retains about 10-percent of body heat to your head. The beanie is soft, consisting of ultrasoft, brushed fleece. The one-size-fits-all winter hat also has a UA Storm technology coating that keeps it breathable and expels water. There are 12 different colors to choose from, including various shades of reds, blues, and grays. Some things to consider are that the beanie isn't windproof and that it doesn't cover the ears completely, which can be very sensitive to the cold during the winter.