Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products and services; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Johnson Silver Minnow Spoon at Amazon
"This spoon is found in most anglers' tackle boxes and is designed for long casts."
Best Crankbait: Rapala Super Shad Rap at Bass Pro Shops
"This is a great all-around lure that can be used for saltwater species as well."
Best Spinnerbait: Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait at Amazon
"This half ounce spinnerbait is almost guaranteed to generate a frenzy."
Best Spoon: Eppinger Original Dardevle Spoon at Amazon
"Its concave shape gives it a unique wiggling and wobbling action."
Best Topwater: Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Lure at Amazon
"The added weight in the tail produces a smooth "walk to the dog" action that predators love."
Best Jerkbait: Rapala X-Rap Jerkbait XR10 Fishing Lure at Bass Pro Shops
"Guaranteed to trigger bites, especially as the lure suspends and comes to a roll at rest"
Best Swimbait: Strike King Shadalicious Swimbait at Amazon
"Its soft plastic body allows it to accurately mimic the natural swimming action of smaller fish."
Best Bucktail Jig: Northland Tackle Bionic Bucktail Fishing Jig at Amazon
"Ideal for trolling along drop-offs and weedlines in search of lurking pike."
Best Paddle Tail: Musky Innovations Magnum Swimmin’ Dawg Pike Lure at Amazon
"The swimbait’s paddle tail creates huge vibrations and acts as a siren call for big predators."
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Johnson Silver Minnow Spoon
Metal fishing spoons work very well with pike because they are easy to cast and bite onto. For this reason, the Johnson Silver Moon Spoon is found in most anglers' tackle boxes. This highly-reviewed soon is designed for long casts. It's made out of silver or gold and works well in fresh or saltwater. The lure's heavier materials also work well in heavy vegetation and won't snag on weeds.
It features a 35-degree angle in the body, that's thicker in the middle, which makes it easy to rock the lure back and forth when you retrieve it. This rocking motion emulates the motion of real bait so the pike will be attracted and bite onto your lure. The spoon can also be jigged, trolled, or twitched to accommodate different preferences and weather conditions. Sizes range from 1 1/8 inch to 3 3/4 inches and are available in 1/4 ounce to 3/4-ounce weights. It comes in classic colors like red and white, to more natural-looking patterns like chrome trout.
Best Crankbait: Rapala Super Shad Rap
Measuring 5.5” in length, the Rapala Super Shad Rap is the plus-sized version of the brand’s tried and true Shad Rap and is ideally suited to targeting northern pike and muskies. It can be cast or trolled and has heavy-duty hardware capable of standing up to aggressive strikes. This includes stainless steel through wire construction to stop the crankbait from disintegrating when seized by strong teeth; and two super sharp VMC black nickel treble hooks. The lure weighs 1-5/8 ounces and has a running depth of 5 to 9 feet.
The body is made of premium Balsa wood. It is hand-tuned and tank-tested to give it a natural swimming action right out of the box, while the baitfish profile replicates the pike’s natural forage. This illusion is reinforced by life-like patterns such as shad, perch, or mullet. When the weather’s overcast or you’re fishing in dirty water, opt for highly visible color patterns like Redhead or Firetiger instead. This is a great all-around lure that can be used for saltwater species as well.
Best Spinnerbait: Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait
Spinnerbaits are a popular choice when fishing in the heavy vegetation that pike tend to favor. This is because their framed design helps to keep weeds away from the hook, therefore reducing your chances of getting stuck. The Booyah Pikee Spinnerbait was specifically created with northern pike and muskies in mind. The super tough Vibra-Flx wireframe is capable of withstanding the species’ teeth, while the included 12” steel leader stops them from biting through your line.
Of course, the ability to survive a strike only matters if you’re getting bites in the first place, and this half ounce spinnerbait is almost guaranteed to generate a frenzy thanks to its double willow blades and Silo-Tex skirt. The former creates irresistible vibration and shine, while the latter mimics the undulating action of a baitfish in distress. A realistic fish head with an oversized eye and painted gill plate adds to the overall effect. Color options include crawfish, perch, sunfish and luminescent glowtreuse.
Best Spoon: Eppinger Original Dardevle Spoon
Pike spoons come in an astounding variety of shapes, sizes, and colors but for many anglers, it’s still impossible to beat the Eppinger Original Dardevle Spoon. Made in the USA, this is a classic lure that has proven irresistible to pike (and other freshwater gamefish) for over 100 years. Its concave shape gives it a unique wiggling and wobbling action that sends out all the flash and vibration you need to attract the attention of a record water wolf. Made of metal and with a single razor-sharp treble hook, the spoon weighs 3/4 ounces.
There are many different sizes and colors available, ranging from the original red/white stripe to more recent innovations like rainbow trout and mackerel. For many angling experts, the yellow/red diamond pattern linked here is the ultimate addition to your tackle box for targeting pike. The spoon can be cast or trolled, depending on your preference and the conditions on any given day.
Best Topwater: Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Lure
Topwater lures like the Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper are ideal for enticing active pike to perform dramatic surface strikes. Made of durable plastic material, this lure comes in 6 inch or 7-inch sizes, so it's big enough for northern pike to grab onto. It's designed with added weight in the tail section which forces the lure to sit tail down. This creates an effective bobbing target and makes the same sounds as fleeing baitfish. It also produces a smooth "walk the dog" action that hungry predators find irresistible.
The Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper is equipped with two premium rust-resistant hooks, which results in fewer losses. There are 20 realistic color patterns to choose from, including bone, mullet, and gold black back. Some have painted scales, fins, and gill plates while others, like the deadly white red head, rely on their high shine to replicate baitfish scales and attract bites no matter the water and topside weather conditions.
Best Jerkbait: Rapala X-Rap Jerkbait XR10 Fishing Lure
Like the Super Shad Rap, the Rapala X-Rap features stainless steel through wire construction and two VMC black nickel treble hooks. By manipulating the jerkbait’s movement, you can achieve an aggressive Slashbait action or the classic Rapala wobble. Both are guaranteed to trigger bites, especially as the lure suspends and comes to a roll at rest, providing a vulnerable target that’s impossible for pike to ignore. Its aerodynamic shape and internal long-cast system allow you to cover more water and get more bites.
The diving lip on the XR10 model gives the lure a running depth of 4 to 6 feet. At 4 inches, it’s ideally sized for pike and comes in a range of iridescent colors that imitate their natural prey. Patterns include clown, glass ghost, and olive green. All lures have a textured, translucent body with an internal holographic foil, a 3D holographic eye, prominent scales, and a lateral line that catches and reflects light underwater. All of these elements combine to create an ultra-realistic baitfish presentation, with a flash foil teaser tail for added shine and movement.
Best Swimbait: Strike King Shadalicious Swimbait
Strike King Shadlicious Swimbait is intended specifically for pike, muskies, and trophy bass. Its soft plastic body allows it to accurately mimic the natural swimming action of smaller fish and allows it to sink into the water slowly adding more life-like effects. The lure’s plastic curly tail gives it a frantic back-and-forth motion that pushes pike into hunting mode.
This lure can be attached to a jighead, an internal jighead, or a weighted hook. Buyers should note, however, that the hook size should match the bait's size. Its realistic fins, 3D eyes, and painted gill plate and scales all add to the overall lifelike effect. With ten colors to choose from, you'll be able to find a lure to suit every conceivable weather and water condition.
Best Bucktail Jig: Northland Tackle Bionic Bucktail Fishing Jig
The Northland Tackle Bionic Bucktail Fishing Jig is ideal for trolling along drop-offs and weedlines in search of lurking pike, or for targeting trophy fish in deep water. The hand-tied genuine bucktail and realistic jig head replicate the size, shape, and pulsating movement of pike forage species such as cisco, alewife, and perch; and the illusion is completed by an oversized reflective eye. Use the center tie-eye for vertical jigging and the forward eye-tie for casting and trolling.
The lure is equipped with a single jig hook and a trailing treble hook that’s cleverly hidden in the bucktail for hooking short-striking pike. The latter is attached with a steel leader, so there’s no chance of your catch being able to bite through the wire and swim free. The lure weighs 3/4 ounces and comes in several different colors including white cisco and glow rainbow. Patriots will like the fact that these quality lures are made right here in the USA.
Best Paddle Tail: Musky Innovations Magnum Swimmin’ Dawg Pike Lure
At 11” and 7 ounces, the Musky Innovations Magnum Swimmin’ Dawg is made with serious pike and muskies in mind. Designed by professional guide Luke Ronnestrand, the swimbait’s paddle tail creates huge vibrations and acts as a siren call for big predators. The lure is made out of incredibly flexible soft plastic, giving it a realistic swimming action. There are two treble hooks, the first of which is mounted on the front to allow for successful hooking of head-hunting fish or fish that strike on the fall. Reel it in smoothly, or with a tantalizing pull/pause action.
Hand poured and painted in the USA, the lure comes in a range of super-realistic baitfish patterns including crappie, bluegill, walleye, and orange belly perch. The lure linked here is the highly effective firetiger. All options are built with a flexible internal harness for added durability. A custom formed, reusable clamshell packet helps to maintain the body shape in your tackle box or for long-term storage.