United States New York The Best New York City Hotels The Carlyle is our top pick for best New York City Hotel By Laura Itzkowitz Laura Itzkowitz Freelance Writer & Editor Instagram Twitter Columbia University Smith College Laura Itzkowitz is a freelance writer and editor based in Rome. Her writing has appeared in Travel + Leisure, Architectural Digest, Surface Magazine, and other publications. TripSavvy's editorial guidelines Updated on 01/11/23 Fact checked by Erin Medlicott Fact checked by Erin Medlicott LinkedIn Twitter New York University Rutgers University Erin Medlicott is a fact checker and researcher with a background in lifestyle and finance. Prior to her work at TripSavvy, she did financial research for the American Express Departures Magazine as well as the Wall Street Journal. She earned a TripSavvy's fact-checking Share Pin Email Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links. Like the city itself, the Big Apple’s best hotels are diverse and dynamic, ranging from micro hotels with tiny rooms to opulent grand dames with trendy restaurants. In fact, there are so many options that booking can feel overwhelming. To make the process a little easier, we’ve narrowed down a list to the category-topping hotels we think are best suited to different kinds of trips, whether you’re planning a big family vacation or just passing through. Read on for our expert list of the best NYC hotels. 8 Best New York City Hotels of 2023 Best Overall: The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel Best Luxury: Baccarat Hotel Best Budget: The Hoxton Williamsburg Best for Families: The Peninsula New York Best Historical Property: The St. Regis New York Best Brooklyn Property: The Wythe Hotel Best Scene: ModernHaus SoHo Best Airport Hotel: TWA Hotel The Best New York City Hotels View All The Best New York City Hotels Our Top Picks The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel Baccarat Hotel The Hoxton Williamsburg The Peninsula New York The St. Regis New York The Wythe Hotel ModernHaus SoHo TWA Hotel See More (5) Final Verdict Compare Hotels Methodology Best Overall : The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It This uptown institution offers a taste of New York elegance at its best, plus can’t-beat proximity to the park. Notable Amenities Valmont Spa, Yves Durif salon, 24/7 fitness center, curated experiences like martini masterclasses and a day at the museum (at an additional cost) Pros and Cons Pros Prestigious Upper East Side location Impeccable white-glove service Fabulous dining and drinking options Good chance of celebrity sightings Cons High price tag, especially in peak seasons Can be hard to get a table at Bemelmans Bar Hotel Overview In a city full of fabulous hotels, the Carlyle is one of the few that rises to the level of iconic. Since opening in 1931, it has hosted presidents, royalty, and celebrities. Michael Jackson and Princess Diana famously met in the hotel’s elevator. And between the luxurious accommodations (many of them recently renovated by lauded designer Alexandra Champalimaud), its discreet white-glove service, and incredible drinking and dining options, it’s no wonder so many illustrious guests choose it as their home away from home in New York City. When it comes to dining and drinking, you’re spoiled for choice. With its hand-painted murals by Ludwig Bemelmans (author of the Madeline children’s books), live music, and the best martini in the city—Bemelmans Bar is the quintessential New York hotel bar. We also love the new restaurant Dowling’s at the Carlyle, which serves classic American fare like lobster bisque and Caesar salads. And if you’re looking for something between lunch and dinner, book an afternoon tea at the Gallery. Best Luxury : Baccarat Hotel Eric Laignel/Courtesy of Baccarat Hotel New York See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It The first-ever hotel by the high-end crystal company has all the glitz and glamor you would expect. Notable Amenities Indoor pool, fitness center with Technogym equipment, house car service within 15 blocks of the hotel Pros and Cons Pros Opulent design dripping with crystal Midtown location right across from MoMA Gorgeous bar with fantastic cocktails Wonderful afternoon tea Guests rave about the kind and attentive staff Cons Everything is expensive, from the cocktails to the rooms Hotel Overview Located right across from MoMA, this five-star hotel is a study in French opulence with around 15,000 pieces of Baccarat crystal. Parquet floors, massive chandeliers, cashmere throws, and red roses create a romantic, sophisticated atmosphere. The bar, with its red walls and checkerboard floors, is especially dramatic. Cocktails are served in Baccarat crystal glasses, naturally. Menus at the various dining outlets are curated by Gabriel Kreuther, the Alsatian chef whose namesake restaurant boasts two Michelin stars. The hotel is also home to the only dedicated spa in the U.S. by luxurious beauty brand La Mer. Neighborhoods to Know Best Budget : The Hoxton Williamsburg Courtesy of The Hoxton See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It This stylish hotspot proves you don’t have to sacrifice style to stay in a hotel that won’t break the bank. Notable Amenities Plush linens by local Brooklyn brand Dusen Dusen, the Apartment event space, complimentary hotel bikes Pros and Cons Pros Great location in hip Williamsburg Rooftop restaurant is a hotspot Stylish design throughout the hotel Cons Rates rise steeply in peak periods Rooms are tiny No gym Hotel Overview British brand the Hoxton makes micro-hotels designed for people who spend more time out and about than in their room. If you don’t mind sleeping in quarters that are a tight squeeze, you’ll enjoy the tradeoff that comes from perks such as having easy access to a spacious lobby lounge that encourages co-working. The rooftop has just been transformed into Laser Wolf, one of the hottest restaurants in the city. It serves Israeli grill fare and mezze by acclaimed Philadelphia chef Michael Solomonov. The staff tries their best to accommodate hotel guests interested in dining here but recommend booking at least two weeks in advance. Best for Families : The Peninsula New York The Peninsula New York See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It This luxurious Midtown hotel pampers little guests with kid-friendly activities. Notable Amenities Salon de Ning rooftop bar, Clement Restaurant, award-winning spa, indoor pool, 24/7 fitness center, hair salon Pros and Cons Pros Great location on Fifth Avenue in Midtown Lots of amenities for the whole family Excellent service Cons Some reviews note dated decor and tech Expensive Hotel Overview Located on Fifth Avenue and 55th Street, the Peninsula gets high marks for outstanding amenities and excellent service and the staff welcome little ones. Guests who book the Family Escape package get daily American breakfast for two adults and two kids, a complimentary rollaway bed or crib, a welcome amenity, and tickets to either MoMA or Top of the Rock. And with Camp Peninsula, kids get a mini tent with a plush campfire and s’mores, their own kid-sized robe and slippers, and an invitation to participate in a scavenger hunt throughout the hotel. Best Historical Property : The St. Regis New York Courtesy of The St. Regis New York See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It This legendary hotel has been welcoming guests to its hallowed halls in midtown for more than a century. Notable Amenities The Cognac Room for lounging, gym with personal trainers, access to yoga and pilates instructors upon request, complimentary car service within a 10-block radius of the hotel Pros and Cons Pros Historic heritage Opulent decor with modern amenities All rooms have butler service Cons Very expensive Some guest reviews note confusing fees and credits Some furniture shows signs of wear and tear Hotel Overview For a taste of Gilded Age New York, the St. Regis is a sure bet. Founded in 1904 by John Jacob Astor IV, this grand dame proudly displays its pedigree with ceiling frescoes in the lobby, gilded pandeling, crystal chandeliers, damask fabrics, and striped wallpaper. Modern comforts include Smart TVs and a small television hidden in the bathroom mirror. Though the rooms lack coffee machines, the butler will bring a pot of French press coffee or tea in the mornings and is available for laundry service, ironing, and other requests. Don’t skip cocktails at the King Cole Bar, with its mural by Maxfield Parrish, which claims to be the birthplace of the Red Snapper (aka the Bloody Mary). Best Brooklyn Property : The Wythe Hotel Adrian Gaut - Courtesy of Wythe See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It Williamsburg’s first boutique hotel is still its best, thanks to its hip style, friendly service, and must-visit restaurant and rooftop bar. Notable Amenities Two notable restaurants, cinema, minibar curated with local products Pros and Cons Pros Great location in hip Williamsburg Acclaimed restaurant and rooftop bar Amazing collection of art by local artists Friendly staff Cons No slippers in the rooms No gym or spa Hotel Overview When the Wythe Hotel opened in 2012, it was the first boutique hotel in Williamsburg, a neighborhood known as a hip, artsy enclave. It has evolved considerably since then and still offers the same industrial-chic style and friendly service, but with a new ground-floor restaurant and rooftop bar that both have a strong local following. Bar Blondeau is a popular spot for creative cocktails and small bites with amazing views of the Manhattan skyline, while Le Crocodile serves French fare by the team behind neighboring Greenpoint’s acclaimed restaurant Chez Ma Tante. Best Scene : ModernHaus SoHo ModernHaus SoHo See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It This chic hotel in trendy Soho boasts one of New York’s best rooftop bars and a restaurant by acclaimed chef George Mendes. Notable Amenities Multiple indoor and outdoor meeting spaces, fitness center with Technogym equipment and a Peloton bike, complimentary bikes available Pros and Cons Pros The rooftop bar is a local favorite The restaurant is run by a Michelin-starred chef Blue chip art collection Pet amenities available Cons Views aren’t as good in rooms on the lower floors $45 facility fee Hotel Overview Formerly the James, ModernHaus SoHo is a sleek hotel in the heart of Soho that offers easy access to lots of great restaurants, bars, designer shops, and multiple subway stations. The design is tasteful and modern with blue chip art by the likes of Alexander Calder and KAWS. The rooftop bar JIMMY draws a cool crowd for cocktails, by acclaimed bartender Johnny Swet, with fantastic views of downtown New York and the Freedom Tower. Veranda serves delicious globally-inspired cuisine like Hamachi Crudo and Piri-Piri chicken by Michelin-starred Portuguese chef George Mendes. The facilities fee grants you a welcome cocktail and 10% off drinks at Jumpin Jacks, where breakfast is served, as well as the use of bikes, 24/7 concierge services, and more. During the day, hotel guests can use the rooftop pool. Best Airport Hotel : TWA Hotel Courtesy of TWA Hotel See Rates on Tripadvisor.com Why We Chose It Located in the landmarked TWA Flight Center at JFK Airport, this might be the coolest airport hotel in the U.S. Notable Amenities Paris Café by Jean-Georges, Connie cocktail bar in a restored 1958 airplane, heated rooftop pool, 10,000-square-foot gym with a Peloton room and yoga studio Pros and Cons Pros Landmarked 1962 building by Eero Saarinen Vintage style paired with modern amenities Great dining and drinking options Nostalgic TWA memorabilia Cons Only really makes sense to stay if you’re traveling through JFK Some guest reviews complain about inconsistent service $25 fee to use the pool No closets in the rooms Hotel Overview Airport hotels aren’t typically known as appealing options, but the TWA Hotel at JFK Airport is an exception. Housed in the 1962 TWA Flight Center designed by Eero Saarinen, it feels like time traveling to the Jet Age when air travel was glamorous. Public spaces, including the restaurants and bars, are in the Saarinen building, while rooms are located in two newly built towers flanking it. Even in the rooms, the design leans into ‘60s nostalgia, with rotary phones, mid-century modern furniture designed by Saarinen himself, and vintage TWA posters. The location isn’t ideal for exploring New York, but it makes sense to stay here for a night if you have to catch an early flight the next morning. Final Verdict When deciding where to stay in New York City, location will surely be an important consideration, so think about what neighborhood you want to stay in and how you’re going to get around. Want to stay in Midtown with easy access to Central Park, plenty of shopping, and cultural attractions? The St. Regis or the Peninsula are great options. Prefer the hip vibes of Soho or Williamsburg? Consider Modernhaus Soho or the Wythe Hotel. Craving the genteel elegance of the Upper East Side? You can’t go wrong at the Carlyle. Compare The Best New York City Hotels Property Resort Fee Room Rates Free Wi-Fi The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel Best Overall No $$$$ Yes Baccarat Hotel Best Luxury No $$$$ Yes The Hoxton Williamsburg Best Budget No $$ Yes The Peninsula New York Best for Families No $$$$ Yes The St. Regis New York Best Historical Property No $$$$ Yes The Wythe Hotel Best Brooklyn Property No $$$ Yes ModernHaus SoHo Best Scene $45 facilities fee $$$ Yes TWA Hotel Best Airport Hotel $22.75 facility fee & taxes $$ Yes Methodology We evaluated about 50 hotels in New York City before settling on the best one for each category. We considered each hotel’s overall reputation, guest reviews, location, quality of service, design, and dining and drinking options. Additionally, amenities such as kids’ clubs, programming, spa and fitness facilities, concierge services, and free Wifi were taken into account. We also considered whether the hotel is new or if it has undergone a recent renovation or update. We relied heavily on our expert’s first-hand experience, but also consulted dozens of guest reviews and looked at whether the property has won any awards in recent years. This view from Chinatown is a popular place for tourists to venture in NYC. FilippoBacci / Getty Images Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Share Pin Email Tell us why! Submit Newsletter Sign Up By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies