Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products and services; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Best Overall: Muck Boot Men’s Arctic Pro Snow Boots at Amazon
"Rated down to -60 degrees and features rubberized outsoles for an added buffer from the ice."
"These affordable boots come with a top drawstring that keeps snow out as you trudge onto the ice."
Best for Extreme Cold: Baffin Men's Snow Monster Boots at Amazon
"The eight-layer insulation system offers protection against the cold down to -70 degrees."
Best for Men: Baffin Men's Wolf Winter Boots at Amazon
"Buckling straps at the ankle and calf give a snug fit without compressing the insulation."
Best for Women: Muck Boot Women’s Arctic Ice Tall Boots at Amazon
"The midsole is contoured for women and helps protect against blisters and chafing."
Most Stylish: Sorel Men's 1964 Pac Nylon Boots at Amazon
"You get form and function in the fluffy sherpa pile snow cuff which keeps snow out while adding flair."
Most Comfortable: Cabela's Men's Inferno Boa Waterproof Boots at Cabela's
"The Boa lacing system gives a comfortable fit with no tying required."
"Nimble enough for hiking in early winter snows and warm enough for long sits in the ice hut."
"L.L. Bean's steel studded cleats slip over your boots to provide maximum traction on the ice."
Any ice fishing enthusiast knows that hands and feet are the first things to get cold when you’re trying to land a lunker on a long sit on the ice. Luckily for all of us, cold-weather boots get better every year, with the latest technology and materials incorporated into every pair of boots. Whether you’re hiking long distances to your lake or just strolling out of the vehicle into a shelter, there’s a boot for you.
Read on to learn more about the best ice fishing boots available.
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: Muck Boot Men’s Arctic Pro Snow Boots
These camouflage duck-hunting style tall neoprene boots from Muck Boot are fully waterproof, of course, but also sport a fleece lining, padded sole, and insulation that makes these boots comfort-rated all the way down to -60 degrees. If it gets colder than that where you fish, you should probably take that day off!
The neoprene outer gives the waterproofing of rubber without the weight and stiffness. They also feature durable rubberized outsoles that are lugged and extra thick for an added buffer from the ice.
Best Budget: ArcticShield Men's Insulated Tall Winter Boots
While these affordable winter boots from ArcticShield may not sport the fancy trademark names such as Gore-Tex and Thinsulate, they come with all the features you want at big savings. The 8-millimeter liner makes these boots rated down to -40 degrees and the top drawstring keeps snow out as you trudge out onto the ice. There’s also a mid-foot Velcro strap to make sure the boots fit snugly, a consistent issue with other bulky winter boots.
The boots are water-resistant, not waterproof, so you’ll want to keep looking if you have long treks to the ice or expect to be in really wet snow. But for the price, you get a boot that will keep you warm in the dead of winter without emptying your wallet.
Best for Extreme Cold: Baffin Men's Snow Monster Boots
While they don’t look much different than many other winter boots, these are the most durable in Baffin’s line of extreme cold weather boots. Rated for as low as -70 degrees, the eight-layer insulation system offers the most protection against the cold that human ingenuity has to offer. Whether you’re fishing in one of the extremes of the Earth or just have zero tolerance for cold, these boots are the ones to grab when warmth is the most important factor. The boots include a number of Baffin’s proprietary technologies from Timberwolf leather and Diamond-Lite insulated upper to the IceClaw outsole for maximum traction.
Best for Men: Baffin Men's Wolf Winter Boots
Baffin specializes in winter boots for extremely cold parts of the world and these Wolf boots are built for the elements. The five-layer insulation system with Thermaplush combined with a cold-resistant outsole creates complete protection from the cold down to -40 degrees. Buckling straps at the ankle and calf cinch the upper boot as-needed for a snug fit without compressing the insulation. On top, the locking cinch snow collar keeps snow out when you're on the way to the ice and back.
Best for Women: Muck Boot Women’s Arctic Ice Tall Boots
These tall wader-type boots from Muck Boot aren’t just men’s boots with a flash of pink. The midsole is cut specifically for a woman’s foot but features the same light flexible waterproof 8-millimeter neoprene outer as the men’s version. This contoured fit also helps protect against blisters and chafing. Forget your worries about cold feet in the ice shack: these boots are comfort rated down to -60 degrees. The Arctic Grip Vibram outsole also ensures reliable traction walking on ice.
Most Stylish: Sorel Men's 1964 Pac Nylon Boots
Face it: most winter boots lack style in favor of cold-weather performance. These classic boots from Sorel let you have it both ways. The duck-boot rubber lower keeps water and wet snow at bay, while the waterproof nylon upper does the same. In the style department, the nylon upper comes in several different colorways. You get both form and function in the fluffy sherpa pile snow cuff which keeps snow out while adding a little flair at the top of the boot. A similar version for women is also available.
Most Comfortable: Cabela's Men's Inferno Boa Waterproof Boots
These snowboard boot-style winter boots incorporate the Boa lacing system that snow sports enthusiasts will recognize. The laceless system gives a comfortable fit with no tying required and makes for a sure, snug fit that’s evenly distributed across the lacing area. This is a proven technology you’ll appreciate most when your hands are cold and clumsy.
In addition to being 100 percent waterproof, the Inferno boots boast an impressive 2,000 grams of Thinsulate insulation, meaning you’ll be able to withstand long sits on the ice without letting cold feet be the reason you pack up early. However, the manufacturer recommends getting a size up if you'll be wearing these ice fishing boots with thick socks.
Best Splurge: Kenetrek Men's Mountain Extreme 400 Insulated Boots
Kenetrek is known for quality in the hunting boot space and these 400-gram insulated winter boots are in the same hunting boot mold but are insulated instead. They're 10 inches tall and fitted with 2.8 millimeter-thick leather all the way up on the uppers.
This is a great boot for the ice fisher who also wants an extra-warm boot that’s nimble enough for hiking in early winter snows. That's because these are fully waterproof and warm enough for long sits in the treestand as well as the ice hut. The rugged outsoles also provide traction to help you hike there easily.
Best Cleats: L.L. Bean Stabilicers Walk Traction Device
Even the best outsoles aren’t a guarantee against slipping on really smooth, slick ice. If traction is a top concern for you, consider adding a pair of cleats. The steel studded Stabilicers from L.L. Bean are an affordable solution that slips over your boots to provide maximum traction when you need it and easy removal when you don’t.
We love the Arctic Pro Snow Boots from Muck Boot (view at Amazon) for their tall fleece-lined inner shell that can keep feet warm down to -60 degrees. The rubberized outsole also helps keep you sturdy while walking on ice. If you only go ice fishing a few times a year and want something more affordable, we recommend the ArticShield Winter Boots (view at Amazon) for their drawstring top and 8-millimeter lining.