United States New York Long Island Best Montauk Hotels The boutique hotel Montauk Beach House tops our list By Virginia Blair West Virginia Blair West Writer Instagram LinkedIn Connecticut College Virginia Blair West is a New York City-based travel writer who also has experience as an editor, advisor, and PR professional. Her work has appeared in Newsweek and Indagare. TripSavvy's editorial guidelines Updated on 06/30/21 Fact checked by Leila Najafi Fact checked by Leila Najafi Instagram LinkedIn Twitter Leila is an L.A.-based luxury travel and lifestyle writer with over five years of experience covering destination guides, hotel reviews, restaurant openings, travel rewards programs, and buying guides. TripSavvy's fact-checking Share Pin Email Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links. From New York City, head east—and we mean all the way east, until the road ends and you see the ocean—and you’ll be in Montauk, the fishing village turned Hamptons hotspot beloved for its gorgeous beaches and breezy hotels. Thanks to the destination’s perennial popularity, there is a hotel for every type of traveler, including stately mansions, stylish boutiques, and big-ticket resorts on the waterfront. When choosing where to stay in Montauk, consider the type of "Out East" experience you’re looking to have, whether it’s a cosmopolitan weekend or off-the-grid getaway. Next, weigh the importance of amenities and services (such as dog-friendliness or in-room kitchens). Here, we narrow down the category-topping properties that are ideal for a stay in this summertime retreat. Read on for our expert list of the best hotels in Montauk. The 8 Best Montauk Hotels of 2022 Best Overall: Montauk Beach House Best Resort: Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Best Boutique: Hero Beach Club Best Budget: Kenny’s Tipperary Inn Best for Families: Ocean Surf Resort Best Hideaway: Driftwood On The Ocean Best Scene: Surf Lodge Best for the Off-Season: Montauk Manor Best Montauk Hotels View All Best Montauk Hotels Montauk Beach House Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Hero Beach Club Kenny’s Tipperary Inn Ocean Surf Resort Driftwood On The Ocean Surf Lodge Montauk Manor Final Verdict Compare Hotels Methodology Best Overall : Montauk Beach House Courtesy of Montauk Beach House See Rates Why We Chose It This boutique hotel tops the chart for its ideal location, coastal-chic decor, and social atmosphere. Pros & Cons Pros On-site restaurant with ultra-fresh seasonal cuisine Two outdoor pools Cons DJ nights can be noisy No spa or fitness center Located a block from the beach in the heart of downtown, this hotel delivers a taste of Montauk at its most stylish. Rooms are designed to beach-house perfection, with white-washed oak flooring, exposed beam ceilings, claw-foot tubs, and handsome navy walls. Through the airy, contemporary art-filled lobby (where pastries and coffee are served), guests can be found sunning on colorful chaise lounges by the pools or sipping cocktails by the fire pits beneath string lights. Notable Amenities Calendar of pop-up eventsEspresso bar Best Resort : Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Courtesy of Gurney's See Rates Why We Chose It This Hamptons institution spoils guests with an indulgent spa, excellent beach, and five-star dining. Pros & Cons Pros Privileged location on a 2,000-foot stretch of private beach 30,000-square-foot Seawater Spa with Roman baths and cutting-edge treatments (currently under renovation) Cons Large resort lacks personalized service Reservations at the restaurants are hard to come by and do not prioritize hotel guests With resorts in Newport and Star Island, Gurney’s has perfected the East Coast beach resort experience, and the ever-popular Montauk location is still one of the best places to stay Out East. Modern guest rooms are appointed with smart technology and walk-in rain showers; and steps from the beach, a collection of wooden cottages boast kitchenettes, fireplaces, and terraces. Guests can spend their days actively (with watersports, tennis, yoga, and fitness classes on offer) or leisurely (the Seawater Spa is a wellness destination in itself). World-class cuisine is guaranteed at the several buzzy restaurants, including Scarpetta, the outpost of the Manhattan hotspot. Notable Amenities Kid’s Club and family activities (like an Easter egg hunt)Surf lessonsSeasonal pop-ups Best Boutique : Hero Beach Club Hero Beach Club See Rates Why We Chose It This intimate and understated beach oasis is the top pick for design lovers in Montauk. Pros & Cons Pros Location on Kirk Park “Umbrella” Beach, within walking distance of downtown Montauk Mobility- and hearing- accessible rooms Cons No restaurant No fitness center, though pilates and yoga are offered This 1950s motel was reimagined as a boutique hotel in 2017 when a heavy dose of style was added to its enviable beachfront setting. Rooms are designed with soaring, exposed-beamed ceilings, contemporary artwork, and funky carpets, and boast luxuries like in-room Tablets and Hill House Home linens. On the sweeping lawn, contemporary sculptures and views of the surrounding dunes are the backdrop for wellness classes and live music. And while the serene outdoor pool is decorated with Balinese furniture and colorful plant life, the real star is the beach, with its umbrellas and bean bags on the powdery sand. Notable Amenities Complimentary bagels and coffeePop-up movie nights and culinary experiences Best Budget : Kenny’s Tipperary Inn Kenny’s Tipperary Inn See Rates Why We Chose It Located on the harbor, this inn delivers a taste of old-school Montauk. Pros & Cons Pros Pet-friendly Welcoming local staff Cons Location is not walking distance from town or beach Room decor lacks character While Kenny’s Tipperary Inn lacks the glitz of newer Montauk hotels, its laid-back atmosphere and lovely landscaped gardens make it a great option for travelers on a budget. Guests stay in comfortable, no-frills accommodations, which range from modest one-bedrooms to apartment-style suites with full kitchens. Most time will be spent outdoors, admiring the hotel’s recently debuted zen garden (with a cascading waterfall and tranquil music), which is located beside its seasonal pool shaded by tiki umbrellas. Notable Amenities Patio with barbequesGarden gazebo Best for Families : Ocean Surf Resort Ocean Surf Resort See Rates Why We Chose It With its heated pool overlooking the beach and well-equipped rooms, families can’t go wrong with Ocean Surf Resort. Pros & Cons Pros Direct access to beach Location within walking distance of downtown Montauk Cons No spa or restaurant on-site Room decor is bare-bones With a baby-blue facade, this retro boutique hotel delivers an effortless beach vacation. Families will appreciate the spacious room’s ample amenities, including refrigerators, stovetops, microwaves, and coffee makers, along with oceanfront sundecks (in gold and platinum room categories). Days are spent lounging by the beach and pool, and exploring Montauk. The hotel is within walking distance of multiple restaurants, the Hamptons Jitney, and the popular Puff & Putt Family Fun Center. Notable Amenities Barbeque and picnic tableBeach chairs and umbrellas (available to rent) Best Hideaway : Driftwood On The Ocean Driftwood on the Ocean See Rates Why We Chose It This condo-style hotel offers the laid-back seclusion of a private beach house, along with the amenities of a resort. Pros & Cons Pros Beautiful views from the rooms of dunes, ocean, or Hither Hills State Park Rooms feature products and linens from elevated brands like Frette Cons Location is not in walking distance of any sites Some rooms could use a refresh Driftwood is a relaxing haven west of Montauk, on a quiet stretch of beach adjacent to two state parks. Accommodations range from open-plan studios with private terraces to one-and two-bedroom cottages (many of which offer full kitchens). Throughout the property, understated decor is complemented by nautical touches like white-paneled walling, wicker furniture, and accent walls in shades of blue. But the real reason to stay here is the wide open spaces: The expansive grounds feature tennis courts, a playground, and large outdoor pool, which lead to a delightfully quiet beach. Notable Amenities Fitness centerPicnic tables, playground, and barbeques Best Scene : Surf Lodge Courtesy of The Surf Lodge See Rates Why We Chose It While opinions are split on the beach bar turned celebrity hotspot, the Surf Lodge is still the place to see and be seen Out East. Pros & Cons Pros Rooms offer Caspar mattresses and toiletries from Caudalie Many rooms boast private balconies with hammocks Cons Weekend nights will inevitably be noisy Service can be inconsistent, especially on the weekend This Hamptons landmark was one of the spots that put Montauk on the map in the first place, and thanks to its ultra-chic decor, outdoor concerts, and excellent cuisine, it’s still going strong. The Surf Lodge oozes style both inside and outside: Public spaces are filled with upholstered furniture in colorful prints, bright aquamarine walls, and contemporary, surf-themed artwork; outside, an expansive deck with lanterns and funky beach chairs overlooks a calm lake. The open-air restaurant serves fresh-caught seafood and craft cocktails to fuel all-night revelry. Notable Amenities Complimentary bike rentalsOn-site boutique Best for the Off-Season : Montauk Manor Montauk Manor See Rates Why We Chose It With an indoor pool and plentiful amenities, this 1920s manor house offers a great stay in Montauk year-round. Pros & Cons Pros Concierge service to arrange transportation (and beach services during the summer) Many rooms offer kitchens, private balconies, and terraces Cons Driving distance to downtown Montauk Rooms vary in design and size This historic hotel is considered by many to be Montauk’s Grande Dame, located on twelve acres of hilltop grounds with sublime ocean views. Comprised of condo-style apartments, ranging from studios to three bedrooms, the hotel is decorated in a classic Tudor style, with arched entryways leading to stately corridors with chandeliers and high ceilings. Favorite amenities include an Italian restaurant with a lovely garden setting and spa with massages and body treatments on offer. Notable Amenities Tennis and shuffleboard courtElectric car chargerComplimentary shuttle transportation Final Verdict Determining where to stay in Montauk is all about what type of experience you're seeking. Gurney’s appeals to travelers looking to have a flop-and-drop beach vacation. The Surf Lodge, on the other hand, puts travelers at the center of the action. Montauk Beach House offers a nice mix of the two. However, you can’t go wrong with a stay at any one of these standout hotels, as each guarantees a top-notch experience in one of the country’s coolest beach towns. Compare the Best Montauk Hotels Property Resort Fee Rates Rooms WiFi Montauk Beach House Best Overall None $$$ 33 Free Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Best Resort $138 $$$$ 152 Free Hero Beach Club Best Boutique $25 $$$ 30 Free Kenny’s Tipperary Inn Best Budget None $ 33 Free Ocean Surf Resort Best for Families $39 $$$ 26 Free Driftwood On The Ocean Best Hideaway None $$ 52 Free Surf Lodge Best Scene None $$$ 20 Free Montauk Manor Best for the Off-Season None $$ 140 Free How We Chose These Hotels In determining the best hotels in Montauk, we evaluated dozens of properties in town and the surrounding area. We considered such factors as the hotel’s reputation and quality of service, proximity to beach and attractions, and crowd-pleasing amenities (including swimming pools and restaurants). In addition to customer reviews, we noted each of the hotel’s sanitation and cleanliness measures. Was this page helpful? Thanks for letting us know! Share Pin Email Tell us why! Submit By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies