Steak is serious business in Columbus, Ohio. We know our beef. But greater Columbus covers over 200 square miles, so discovering the truly great steakhouses can take time and money. Try the Columbus steakhouses listed below. There are a couple of other well-known, very good steakhouses in the area, but these stand just a bit taller. They begin with melt-in-your-mouth filets and exceptional service and go straight up from there.
The Top Steak House
Why it’s a "Best Columbus Steakhouse": Step into this locally-owned restaurant, and you feel like you’ve stepped into an early 1960s James Bond movie. The place is dark, sleek, and you just know they make a great martini: shaken, not stirred. If you’re not in the mood for beef, The Top also has excellent chicken and daily seafood specials. But here, the specialty is superb beef done to perfection; Rachel Ray Magazine rated the restaurant as one of the top 32 steakhouses in the United States. That’s no surprise to locals.
They’ve enjoyed evenings of fabulous food and live piano playing at The Top for more than 50 years.
Location: 2891 E. Main St., Columbus
Why it’s a "Best Columbus Steakhouse": Eddie’s prices are high for Columbus, but the prime, aged beef, well-selected wine list, and special touches like the smoking shrimp make it worth the visit. Most of the entrées can easily make two meals. Sometimes, featured wines and entrees are offered at small discounts.
Location: 1570 Polaris Parkway (Polaris Parkway and Lyra Drive), Columbus
Why it’s a "Best Columbus Steakhouse": Mitchell’s began as part of Columbus restaurateur Cameron Mitchell’s empire. It quickly became known as one of the places in the Midwest for fine steaks and wine; its wine list earned the 2006 Wine Spectator award of excellence. Cameron sold Mitchell’s to Ruth’s Hospitality Group (owners of Ruth’s Chris Steak House) in 2008. That ownership change did not change the quality of food and service that locals expect from Cameron restaurants. If beef isn’t your thing, take heart because the tuna steak is incredible.
Location: 45 N. Third St., Columbus (Downtown location)
Why it’s a "Best Columbus Steakhouse": The staff is friendly and there is a truly excellent selection of wines by the glass. One word of caution: Hyde Park's different potato offerings range from okay to undercooked to over-seasoned. But the steaks make up for it. Sit at one of the lounge dining tables to watch the fire.
Location: There are three Hyde Parks around Columbus -- downtown, Dublin, and Upper Arlington. The one reviewed here is the downtown site, 569 North High Street, Columbus in the Short North/Cap area.